Comparing Coverland and TigerTough Seat Covers

If you’ve spent any time on Facebook lately, you’ve probably seen the ads: robots fighting bears, over-the-top animations, and some bold claims about Coverland’s premium comfort leather seat covers. They’re flashy. They’re everywhere. And they definitely caught our attention.

But people are asking: Are Coverland seat covers legit? It's a good question to ask when they've got intentionally obvious AI ads.

So we did what we always do. We bought a set, threw them on a truck next to our own TigerTough covers, and took a close, honest look. This is a head-to-head comparison, allowing you to see how the two brands stack up before you spend your hard-earned cash.

What are they made of?

Coverland markets their seat covers as “premium comfort leather.” But let’s clear something up right away: there’s no leather involved. Zero animals were harmed in the making of these seat covers. What you’re actually getting is a polyurethane-coated memory foam. That coating gives the covers a leather-like appearance, while the foam adds cushion. The material is perforated to help with breathability, but polyurethane itself isn’t breathable, and foam tends to trap heat. The polyurethane outer layer is also prone to scratching, especially around seatbelt anchors and sharp tools. These covers aren’t built for daily abuse.

The result? A cover that can get uncomfortably hot in the sun and may hold onto moisture and odors more than you’d like, especially if you’ve got kids, pets, or a tough job that brings the mess inside.

TigerTough covers are crafted from 1,000-denier Cordura, a super durable American-made nylon. There’s no foam, no fake leather, just rugged, breathable fabric designed to take a beating. It resists punctures, abrasions, and moisture, and since there’s no padded backing, you don’t have to worry about it soaking up sweat or slowing down your heated/cooled seat performance.

Material durability

Coverland’s seat covers are made from polyurethane (PU) with a foam backing. PU is a common faux leather alternative, but it comes with some drawbacks:

• It’s prone to cracking and peeling over time—especially in hot vehicles

• The foam backing breaks down with repeated use and exposure to moisture

• Perforated material plus foam = a sponge for sweat, spills, and bacteria

These covers might look high-end at first glance, but they’re not built to take a beating. And because they’re a generic fit, the edges can shift and rub, causing premature wear.

TigerTough seat covers are made from 1,000-denier Cordura—an American-made fabric originally designed for military use. Here’s what that gets you:

• Extreme resistance to abrasion, tearing, and punctures

• Water-resistant and quick to dry

• No foam, so it won’t break down or trap moisture

How do they fit?

Coverland covers are what we’d call a “close fit,” not a true custom fit. That means they’re designed to generally match the shape of your seat, but not conform to it exactly. On camera, they look decent. But in real life, the extra foam and pre-shaped form can leave gaps, wrinkles, and baggy spots, especially around the seat bottom and controls. The result is a cover that holds its shape more than it follows your seat’s shape. Think of it as a pair of coveralls for your seat, rather than a favorite pair of jeans.

The install process uses elastic straps, plastic pieces, and a lot of hardware. And while it does the job, some customers may find the bulkiness and leftover parts a little clunky.

TigerTough covers are custom-measured to each vehicle’s seat, so the fit is snug and precise. They wrap around the full seat, tucking into seams and securing with string locks that cinch the bottom tight. There’s no foam or rigid shaping, so the material molds to the actual contours of your seat…not an imitation of it.

You might notice a few wrinkles when they first go on, but once the covers settle in, they look clean and professional, as if they came with the truck.

Warranty

Coverland advertises “up to a 10-year warranty,” but they don’t spell out what that actually means. There’s no clear breakdown of what’s covered, what isn’t, or how to file a claim. “Up to” can mean just about anything…and that kind of vagueness doesn’t inspire a lot of confidence.

What we know:

• Claims “up to 10 years” of coverage

• No public details on limits or exclusions

• Warranty terms aren’t easy to find or verify
  
  

TigerTough keeps it simple: a 2-year unconditional warranty. If it fails you, we’ll take care of it. No red tape, no fine print, and no judgment.

What that really means:

• Two full years of coverage for any damage, no matter how it happened

• Fast, friendly support from a real human

• We’ll replace or repair your cover, not give you a headache

The bottom line

If you’re just after a quick aesthetic upgrade and don’t mind a little foam, a chemical smell, or a loose fit, Coverland might scratch that itch. But if you're putting your truck to work and want covers that can take a beating, stay snug, and not hold you back with insulation or stink like an old flip-flop, TigerTough’s the clear winner. No gimmicks. No weird Facebook bear ads. Just seat covers that do their job day in, day out. Made in the USA, built to last, and backed with a real-deal warranty. That’s how we roll.

In all honesty, Coverland was one of our least favorite seat covers to review, and we’ve looked at quite a few. Normally, we don’t rank or rate the covers we compare. We just show you what they are so you can decide for yourself. However, in this case, the difference between what was advertised and what you actually received was significant enough that we felt compelled to point it out.

If you don’t think TigerTough is the best fit for you and your truck, that’s totally fine. Here are some other favorite seat cover brands to check out.